
Two years after America’s second war against the British ended , Stephen Decatur famously toasted, “Our country! In her intercourse with foreign nations may she always be in the right; but our country, right or wrong!” Ironically, that kind of somewhat jingoistic statement made today would be seen by some as unpatriotic, or maybe even “communist.” How could America ever be wrong?
For the last 250 years, there have seldom been times when the United States has been wholly in the right vis a vis other nations. Even when wars were ostenisbly fought in self-defense, there were often ulterior motives and opportunism that drove how the wars were fought. *
As a veteran of Operation Earnest Effort to Lower Oil Prices, I’ve muttered Decatur’s words to myself on more than one occasion. And in this moment in time, when so much of what is done in the name of our country is objectively anything but right, those words take on a reformist spin: a patriot should not just accept that the country is wrong, but make it right.
Patriotism, in my mind, is a love of country and its people. It is civic, not political. A patriot steps up to help other people in their country regardless of identity, class, or even immigration status in times of need, and is willing to put the good of the people of the nation ahead of individual ambitions and interests, and strives to make the country right when it isn’t.
Also, patriotism is not performative–you don’t act patriotically to draw attention or glory to yourself. Patriotic acts are by definition giving without any expectation of getting; in wartime, that could include giving your life to protect the lives and rights of people you’ve never met.
This view of patriotism is in direct opposition to what the current regime promotes: division, “nativism,” racism, self-promotion and self-gain, corruption, moral cowardice, and chaos directed at creating conditions suitable for sustained authoritarianism.
MAGAs are not patriots. They are nationalists with an adjective: white, Christian, fascist. Don’t let them challenge your patriotism. And keep fighting to make America right, not right-wing.
*With the exception of the Civil War and the actions against the Barbary Pirates, every war the US undertook in the 19th century had the goal of territorial expansion. The War of 1812 had some core righteous causes (“Free Trade and Sailors’ Rights” is a banger of a rallying cry, Jack McCain). But there were other motivators that may have been less noble. There was territorial expansion on the menu, including seizing land in the west from native tribes that were allied with the British, and goals of annexing Canada outright. “The Quebecios will welcome us with open arms!”…said someone who had never met a Québécois. In the 20th century, US entry into WWI was for a muddled host of reasons; entry into WWII was driven by trade issues and collision of colonial interests in the Pacific, and Korea and Vietnam were driven by “containment” of Communism but also protection of the hegemony the US had inherited from spent allies in Asia. And then there was Reagan…









